• Uncategorized

About bash : Using-a-variable-in-brace-expansion-range-fed-to-a-for-loop

Question Detail

Here is myscript.sh

for i in {1..$1};
    echo $1 $i;

If I run myscript.sh 3 the output is

3 {1..3}

instead of

3 1
3 2
3 3

Clearly $3 contains the right value, so why doesn’t for i in {1..$1} behave the same as if I had written for i in {1..3} directly?

Question Answer

You should use a C-style for loop to accomplish this:

for ((i=1; i<=$1; i++)); do
   echo $i

This avoids external commands and nasty eval statements.

Because brace expansion occurs before expansion of variables. http://www.gnu.org/software/bash/manual/bashref.html#Brace-Expansion.

If you want to use braces, you could so something grim like this:

for i in `eval echo {1..$1}`;
    echo $1 $i;

Summary: Bash is vile.

You can use seq command:

for i in `seq 1 $1`

Or you can use the C-style for...loop:


Here is a way to expand variables inside braces without eval:

declare -a 'range=({'"1..$end"'})'

We now have a nice array of numbers:

for i in ${range[@]};do echo $i;done

I know you’ve mentioned bash in the heading, but I would add that ‘for i in {$1..$2}’ works as intended in zsh. If your system has zsh installed, you can just change your shebang to zsh.

Using zsh with the example ‘for i in {$1..$2}’ also has the added benefit that $1 can be less than $2 and it still works, something that would require quite a bit of messing about if you wanted that kind of flexibility with a C-style for loop.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.